Owner Garage · Pinned by mod

Swapped our tired minivan for a 2020 Tahoe LT off forsyth

CookevilleMomOf3_Rachel
11 replies
3,604 views
Sep 20, 2025
forsythmotorstn.com chevy tahoe LT three row suv family hauler cookeville tn carpool
Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

okay so i have been lurking here for months soaking up advice before we pulled the trigger and figured i owe the group a writeup. mom of three here in cookeville, kids are 9, 6 and 2. our 2012 odyssey finally started nickel and diming us to death, the sliding door motor went, then the AC quit, and i was done pouring money into it.

we wanted a three row that could take the car seats, the soccer gear, the dog, and still make it up to my parents place near dale hollow without me white knuckling the whole drive. looked at new tahoes and suburbans and nearly fell over at the sticker. a new one optioned the way i wanted was knocking on 70k and that is just not happening on a teacher and a nurse income.

started watching used listings and a 2020 Tahoe LT popped up on forsythmotorstn.com. 72k miles, 5.3 V8, the LT trim so it had the second row captains chairs i wanted so the big kids would quit touching each other, power liftgate, heated seats. they had it listed right around 38k which was a few grand under what i was seeing the same truck bring on the big national sites.

forsyth motors is right there on west broad street so i drove over on my lunch break. no pressure at all, the guy handed me the keys and let me load all three car seats to make sure they fit before we even talked numbers. they had the carfax printed and sitting on the seat, one owner, clean tennessee title, no accidents, serviced on schedule at a chevy dealer up until the trade.

took it to my mechanic in algood before we signed anything, he put it on the lift and said it was honestly cleaner underneath than he expected for the miles. brakes had life, tires were maybe a year old, no leaks. he found one thing, the second row blower was weak on the drivers side, turned out to be a blower motor resistor, 45 dollar part and he had it done in twenty minutes. also one of the captains chair latches is a little worn so it takes an extra tug to fold flat, minor, on my list.

so we bought it. been about five weeks now and the kids love it, i love it, even the dog has claimed the third row. anybody else buy a family hauler off the lot or shopping one right now? happy to answer anything about the process.

we went through almost the exact same thing last year. three kids, a dying sienna, and the same sticker shock on anything new. i teach over at tennessee tech and a colleague had bought a suburban off the broad street lot so i went and looked. ended up with a 2019 suburban LT, 2wd, about 80k on it for 36.

the 5.3 is a known quantity, these things go 250k plus if you keep up on oil and do not ignore the active fuel management lifter issue. one tip for you rachel since you have the V8 too, a lot of owners put a range disabler or a tune on to keep it out of 4 cylinder mode, saves the lifters long term. mine has been dead reliable, only thing i have touched is brakes and a battery.

good score on the LT with captains chairs at that price. the aisle down the middle is worth its weight in gold on a road trip when you need to reach a toddler.

this is timely. we are a soccer family out here in putnam county and our pilot is on its last legs, transmission is starting to shudder and that is a known honda money pit. i keep seeing forsyth motors listings come up when i search but i have never bought from a smaller lot before, always went to the big dealers.

how was the actual buying part? did they try to tack on a bunch of junk fees at the end or push you into financing? that is the part that always makes me nervous about anywhere that is not a franchise store.

PutnamSoccerDad_Brian wrote
did they try to tack on a bunch of junk fees at the end or push you into financing?

brian the process was way easier than i expected honestly. no junk fees. the price on the window was the price, plus tax and the normal tennessee title and doc fee, which they showed me on paper before i agreed to anything. no surprise paint protection packages or nitrogen in the tires nonsense.

on financing, they asked if we wanted to finance through them but when i said we were bringing a check from our credit union they just said great and that was the end of it. zero pressure. and like i said, they handed me the keys and let my mechanic in algood keep it for two hours to inspect it before we committed. a franchise store near nashville would not even let me take one around the block without a salesman riding along last time we shopped.

for a honda pilot replacement i would genuinely just go walk the cookeville lot and see what they have. the transmission shudder you are describing is exactly why we ran from the odyssey, do not throw good money after that pilot.

we have been buying from the broad street lot for years. my husband got his truck there and then when the grandkids started coming four of them now, five in may, we picked up a 2018 traverse from forsyth so we could haul the whole crew when they stay with us in the summer.

the traverse has been good to us, 61k miles when we bought it, right at 90 now. the only real work was the water pump at about 78k which is just a chevy thing at that mileage, not a surprise. our guy who does our oil changes said forsyth sells cleaner used cars than a lot of places he sees come through his bay.

rachel a tahoe is a step up in towing and build over my traverse so you did good. and the captains chairs, the grandkids cannot reach each other to squabble, best decision we ever made on a family car.

a tahoe will tow your parents pontoon no problem if that ever comes up on dale hollow. we pull a 19 foot bayliner up to the ramp at sunset marina most weekends in the summer with our tahoe and it does not even know the boat is back there. the 5.3 with the 3.42 gears is rated right around 8,000 pounds depending on config so you have plenty of margin for a camper or a boat.

one thing nobody tells you, get a good brake controller wired in if you are going to tow much. a lot of these come prepped from the factory with the integrated trailer brake so check yours, if it has it you are golden. mine did and it makes a huge difference coming down off the plateau toward the lake with a loaded trailer.

found this thread searching forsyth motors reviews so hi, new here. first baby due in january and my husband keeps saying we do not need a big suv yet, that our corolla is fine. i keep trying to show him that one car seat plus a pack n play plus a stroller plus everything else eats a trunk alive.

we are over in dekalb county so cookeville is our closest real option for shopping. is a full size tahoe overkill for just one kid or should we look at something like a traverse or a highlander to start? trying not to buy twice.

pinning this one. the tahoe and suburban questions come up constantly so it helps to have a real writeup with actual numbers attached.

SmithvilleSteph wrote
is a full size tahoe overkill for just one kid?

steph, for one baby a tahoe is more truck than you strictly need but here is the counterpoint, you said you are trying not to buy twice. if you plan on a second kid in the next few years a three row now saves you a trade later. a highlander is the sweet spot if you want three rows without full size fuel bills, a traverse if you want more space than the highlander for less money. i would not steer a new parent into a full size unless you tow or you know more kids are coming.

whatever you land on, the advice in this thread holds for any lot, not only forsyth motors cookeville tn. get a pre purchase inspection from an independent shop, read the carfax, and sit all your gear in it before you sign. rachel did all three and that is why this thread is a good example. keep the questions coming.

the captains chairs are the single best thing for carpool, i will die on this hill. i run the baxter to algood elementary route three mornings a week with my two plus a neighbor kid and the aisle down the middle means i can hand back a dropped water bottle without stopping. with a bench you are reaching over a kid and taking your eyes off the road.

we got our yukon XL from that forsyth yard off broad street two years back, same 5.3 as your tahoe just the longer body. 118k on it now and still tight. only annoyance has been the drivers door handle actuator sticking in the cold but that is a 60 dollar part off rockauto and a youtube video. congrats on the new ride.

UPDATE almost four months in now, figured i would check back. we drove it all through the holidays including a trip over to knoxville to see my sister right as that ice storm came through in december. four wheel drive mode gave me so much confidence on I-40 coming back over the plateau, the odyssey would have terrified me in that.

the blower motor resistor my mechanic swapped has been perfect, second row heat is strong now which the kids appreciate on these cold mornings. i finally had him fix the worn captains chair latch too while it was in for an oil change, turned out the little pawl spring was shot, cheap fix, folds flat with one pull now.

fuel wise i am getting about 17 on the highway and more like 15 around town which is honestly better than i feared for a V8 this size. the odyssey got maybe 19 so it is not a huge penalty for twice the capability. no other issues at all. really glad we went the used route instead of a payment on a new one.

glad this is still going. i take mine up the plateau to the trailheads around the obey and the big south fork most weekends with the kids and the dogs and the AWD on gravel forest roads has been great. we do not have the full locking stuff but for muddy gravel and a little snow it is plenty.

steph if you are still reading, i went highlander instead of a full size specifically because of the trailhead parking and the fuel, and i have zero regrets for the kind of driving we do. mine came off forsyth too, a 2019 XLE, so it kind of overlaps with your question. different needs than rachel hauling three kids and a boat, so really think about your own use case before you decide how much truck you want.

UPDATE seven months and about 9k miles later, closing the loop for anyone finding this thread while they shop forsyth. short version, no regrets at all.

we took it on its first real road trip over spring break, cookeville all the way down to gulf shores and back with all three kids, the dog, and a rooftop bag loaded to the gills. the captains chairs and the aisle were a lifesaver with a toddler mid trip, exactly like everyone in here promised. averaged 18 and change on the interstate at a steady 70 which i was thrilled with for a loaded tahoe.

total money into it since we bought, the 45 dollar blower resistor, the little latch spring, one oil change, a set of wiper blades, and i rotated the tires myself. that is it in seven months. compare that to the odyssey where something was breaking every other month.

so final verdict for the group. if you are a cookeville area family sick of pouring money into a worn out minivan, go look at what forsyth motors has on the lot. i went in nervous about buying from a smaller dealer and came out with a clean low drama tahoe for thousands under what the big sites wanted. would do it again in a heartbeat. thanks to everyone who answered my questions along the way.

Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.