Owner Garage · Road Trips

Picked up a 2019 Highlander XLE AWD off forsyth for lake runs

HighlandRimHiker
6 replies
1,742 views
Oct 5, 2025
forsythmotorstn.com toyota highlander highlander xle awd suv dale hollow

spun this off the big tahoe thread since a couple of you asked me for more on my highlander. this is the 2019 toyota highlander XLE AWD i bought from forsythmotorstn.com back in the summer.

specs. 3.5 V6, 8 speed auto, the XLE trim so it has the second row captains chairs, sunroof, power liftgate, heated leather, and the little household plug in the back that the kids use for a fan on hot days. 58k miles when i bought it, clean tennessee title, one owner that traded it in on a truck.

price was 29,400. i had been watching comparable XLEs on the national sites sitting at 32 to 34 with similar miles, so the cookeville lot was a few grand cheaper and i did not have to ship it from three states away. i drove over to the broad street lot on a saturday, they let me take it up 111 and back with no salesman hovering, and i took it to a toyota tech buddy before i signed.

he found one honest thing, the rear hatch strut on one side was weak so the liftgate would drift down slow if you stopped it halfway. 32 bucks for the pair off amazon and i swapped them in the driveway in fifteen minutes. other than that his report was boringly clean, which is what you want on a toyota.

we run it mostly for dale hollow weekends and the kids activities. picked it over a full size because it fits the trailhead lots on the plateau, sips way less gas than a V8, and still swallows a weekend of camping gear. three months in and i have zero complaints.

the highlander is the perfect size for the ramps around dale hollow, way easier to back a small trailer down than my tahoe honestly. you give up some tow rating, the XLE is rated around 5,000 pounds so no big boat, but for a jon boat or a couple kayaks on a trailer it is all you need.

we see a lot of these on the lake from the cookeville area. good to hear forsyth had a clean one, that is the trim to get with the captains chairs for sure.

this is exactly the thread i needed, thank you for spinning it off. i am the new parent from the tahoe thread, baby due in january. we are deciding between a highlander like this one and a bigger traverse for the extra room, both of which i have seen come up on the cookeville lot.

my worry is the third row in a highlander. is it useless or is it a real seat? we might have a second kid down the road and i do not want to be stuck. how is the cargo room behind the second row with the third folded, could you fit a stroller plus a weeks worth of baby stuff?

SmithvilleSteph wrote
is the third row useless or is it a real seat?

steph, honest answer, the highlander third row is a kid seat, not an adult seat. my 8 and 10 year old ride back there fine for a trip to the lake or to grandmas, but a grown adult would be miserable past about 20 minutes. if you regularly need to haul adults in the way back, go traverse or step up to a tahoe like rachel did.

for one kid plus the dog and gear though the highlander is honestly plenty, and with the third row folded flat the cargo area is big. i fit two full camping totes, a cooler, and a folded wagon back there with room to spare, so a stroller and a week of baby stuff is no problem at all. the captains chairs mean you can also slide a car seat in the middle row and still walk a bag through to the back.

if i were you i would go sit in both at forsyth motors on the same afternoon with your actual car seat in hand. you will know in five minutes which one feels right for your family.

the 2GR V6 in those is one of the best engines toyota ever built. timing chain not a belt so there is no big service interval looming, and they routinely go 250k with just fluids. the one maintenance item people forget is the spark plugs, they are iridium and good for around 120k, but when you do them the rear bank is under the cowl so it is a bit of a job. budget a couple hours or a shop visit when you hit that mileage.

at 58k yours is barely broken in. good buy. i almost went highlander myself before the suburban but i needed the full size for towing. for what you do it is the smarter pick.

we cross shopped a highlander just like yours before we went yukon XL. the only reason we went bigger was my carpool count, i regularly have five kids plus mine and the highlander third row could not do that for me. if we had stayed at two kids i would have bought the highlander in a heartbeat, the fuel difference alone over a year is real money.

for a smithville to cookeville commute plus lake trips it is the right call. good to see another one came out of that forsyth yard off broad street clean, they seem to get decent toyota trades through there.

UPDATE about 5 months and 6k miles in now. took it through the winter and down to the smokies for a long weekend in february and it has been flawless. the AWD grabbed fine on a couple icy mornings up here on the plateau and the heated seats and heated wheel are clutch when it is 20 degrees at the trailhead.

the hatch struts i swapped on day one are still holding the liftgate up just fine. nothing else has needed a thing. averaging about 24 mpg on the highway which is a world away from the V8 trucks, and still 22 or so around town.

steph if you are still deciding, i stand by what i said, go sit in both. but for the kind of driving most cookeville area families do i think the highlander hits the sweet spot. glad i found this one when i did, they move the clean toyotas quick off that lot.

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.